Sticks and Stones May Break My Bones But I'd rather Make Math Tools with 'em

Agenda

Discuss Ancient Mathematical Tools: What Comes to Mind?
Focus on: Abacus (Chinese) and Chisanbop.

Handouts Needed

Making an Abacus
Chisanbop

Materials

Abacus (Created or Bought)
Hands
Pencil




What is it? Look at the picture above.
Wooden rack of two rows of beads.
Rows are separated by a crossbar.
There are usually between 7 and 13 columns.
Each column has seven beads. Two in the top row "heaven" and five in the bottom
row, "earth".

History:
Developed around 500-550 B.C.
Still widely used in Asia today.

What does an Abacus do?

Add, Subtract, Multiply, Divide in Base 10 (decimal system)
Add and Subtract in Base 2 (Binary)

How do you use the abacus?
Assignment of numbers.
Each column is a power of ten. Much like our decimal system.
Each column represents a power of ten
From left to right in a 7 column abacus
106 10 5 10 4 10 3 102 101 10 0


Each heaven bead is worth 5 * that power of ten
Each earth bead is worth 1 * that power of ten.

So the picture below represents the number 16. Ten is the second column (one bead in earth used)
Five in the first column (One heaven bead used) and One in the first column (One earth bead used).



Adding: Try the following problem.

16+28
Start by setting up the abacus with the 16 as shown then feed in the 28.

You should get this result


Subtracting: Try the following problem.

37-23

Start by setting up the larger number then clear out the number you want to subtract.
Multiplying: Repeated Adding

Try the following
12*5 (Adding 12 five times of 5 is added 12 times)
How do you keep track of each addition sequence?
Try using another unused (prolly far right) column as a tally column to keep a tally of each repeated sequence.

Dividing: Repeated Subtraction
Try the following
28 ÷ 4 (Taking four out of 28 how many times)

keep track of successive divisions same way as above.

What about larger numbers?
How would you go about Subtracting
3872 - 1624
Or Multiplying
12 x 12 without performing 12 additions?
Or 26 x 38?



Relevance to Primary and Secondary Level Educators
Help students develop a sense of numbers and their meaning.
Tool to Aid in performing calculations.
Excellent for students who may still need physical manipulatives as numbers are too abstract. Visually impaired students love this device.
Give students a sense of ownership of the mathematics.
Easy to build and each student can make a powerful computing device of their own.
Estimation is important in checking "right" answer.
Connection to history of mathematics. Mathematics was created by people who used devices such as these.
Often a calculator is blamed for giving quick answers without providing the knowledge necessary to understand these answers. The abacus helps promote the process of obtaining the answer.

Chisanbop

What is it?
Literally, a hand-held calculator requiring only the students' two hands.
History:
Created by Korean teacher, Sung Jin Pai.

Basics:
Each student holds out both hands palm-down and makes two fists.
This represents zero. Now, extend all fingers. This represents 99.
These are the maximum and minimum numbers of our calculator.
The fingers of your left hand are each "worth" 10 and the thumb is "worth" 50.
The fingers of your right hand are each "worth" 1 and the thumb is "worth" 5.
Two thumbs extended equals 55. Two index fingers extended equals 11.
Adding: Try 14 + 23
Subtracting: Try 27 - 18
Multiplying and Dividing: Try the problems presented for use with the abacus and note difficulties and differences.


Relevance to Primary and Secondary Level Educators
Help students develop a sense of numbers and their meaning.
Tool to Aid in performing calculations.
Excellent for students who may still need physical manipulatives as numbers are too abstract. Visually impaired students love this device.
Tool is readily available.
Gives students a sense of ownership of the mathematics.
Estimation is important in checking "right" answer.
Often a calculator is blamed for giving quick answers without providing the knowledge necessary to understand these answers. Chisanbop helps promote the process of obtaining the answer.



Focus Areas of Chisanbop and Abacus

Create and Solve 4 problems. One of Each operation on each "Device"
Try to find some that make you develop a new technique.
Perform the calculation and detail your technique and method.

Answer the following questions on a separate page.

How can these tools promote learning math for all?

How can students benefit from these methods?

Which Tool do you like best? Why?

What are some problems you can imagine with both methods?

How can these problems be remedied?

Knowing what you know from Piagetian Theories of learning, what benefits do you see with using tools such as these in the Primary grades? What about secondary grades?